Language:
Part 1:
1)
This experiment was not difficult for my partner
or me because with how the world is today, in a classroom or in the work
environment where you are told not to speak much, we adapted to reading each
other’s body languages as well as learn to understand the facial language. Making this experiment rather easy.
2)
Like I stated in the first answer, we both are
so used to reading the facial expressions that we both understand what we are
saying without words or sign language rather well. If it were someone else though, I do think
that more hand movements would be coming from him or her as a way to try and
make me help them understand what they are saying.
3)
If we were of two different cultures, the
culture with more verbal understanding would probably have the biggest
advantage because it is easier to say something then to show something in most
cases. When I think of someone who can’t
really communicate with a verbally able person I think of a special needs
student and a “normal” student. Because
of some lack of verbal communication, we tend to talk softer in tone as well as
use hand movements and facial expressions to help out our conversation. I think that would be the attitude that is
shown within two groups of different cultures as well, where the “higher”
culture sort of looks down at the other culture in a soft kind of way.
Part 2:
1)
Because you did say that we needed to do the
experiment for the whole 15 minutes, I would have to say that we struggled, but
did last the 15 minutes. Being that I
did this experiment with my girlfriend, knowing how I would be communicating,
it mad not only her, but me frustrated as well.
Being that we’re usually talking in a way that causes us to laugh or
have “awe” moments, this made the experiment much more difficult than it needed
to be.
2)
This affected my partner because unable to show
any emotion as well as movement to confirm or not confirm something, this made
her rather mad and irritated her.
3)
Non-speech language is very important to our
language and it definitely makes a different when communicating with certain
people. It shows attitude more than any
other emotion. With no other way to
communicate, there is no emotion, so even if you were to say something like “I
miss you”, without the emotion, it almost means nothing.
4)
There are definitely people that can’t read body
language, as an example (just in general) that person that everyone know who
can’t take a hint, when give the facial expression and still won’t leave you
alone until you just walk away. The
ability to read body language and facial expression is a gift and should be
held on to as generations pass because without it, the world will end up
emotionless, making everything pointless and unneeded, but that is just my
opinion. There is not a time where I can
think of a benefit to not being able to read body language would come in handy,
the world can only benefit with it.
I agree with you that familiarity makes the first part of this experiment easier, but does that apply to all topics? What did you talk about? Did your partner change the way he spoke at all during this part of the experiment?
ReplyDeleteGreat analysis of the interaction between the two different cultures. Well done.
Good description of the second part. Why did your partner feel frustration? You were able to use words, so why was the situation frustrating?
For section 4, I know that there are some individuals who tend to just ignore body language, but there are groups, such as those in the autism spectrum, that can't actually read body language.
Are we in danger of losing body language? Your discussion here was odd. Think about why we have body language. There must be a adaptive advantage, correct? Is this cultural or is it biological? Why would we lose it?
For the last question, what about if the body language would give you false information? Think about traveling to another culture that uses different body language. Can you envision a situation where you might get in trouble misreading that new body language?
For the second experiment, my partner got frustrated because showing no emotion she automatically assumed that something was wrong with me.
DeleteI don't think will ever lose body language, but at the same time with technology improving and meeting people through the internet instead of in person, we could lose body language much later on.
As for false information, my experience with that would be the Japanese culture and the culture now. Usually elbows on the table is acceptable (at least from seeing that most people now a days are starting to careless) in the Japanese culture, it will always be impolite to eat with elbows on the table.
Thank you for the response.
Delete